Tippy Type
Enhancing User Experience for Tippy Type: A Case Study in Usability Testing and Design Optimization
Tippytype current website
Team
Trevor Cheron
Tyree
Chad
Role
User Research
Usability Moderator & Note taker
Timeline
5 days
Tools
Figjam
Google Drive
Otter.ai
Process
Heuristic Analysis
Research script
Research Findings & Recommendation
Project Overview
Tippy Type is a small, woman-owned business dedicated to enhancing the typing experience for individuals with long nails. Their flagship product, the "tippy type," is a high-quality silicone keyboard cover that allows for better clearance, resulting in improved typing speed, accuracy, and comfort. As a patent-pending innovation (both in the US and internationally), Tippy Type is currently the only commercial product specifically designed to meet the unique needs of long-nail typists.
In this project, Tippy Type engaged us to assess their website's effectiveness in meeting user expectations, focusing on lead capture and conversion. We conducted usability testing to evaluate the user experience for their target audience—typists with long nails, influencers, and beauty insiders. Our objective was to identify pain points and provide actionable recommendations for enhancing navigation, improving user engagement, and optimizing the overall user experience on the site.
Problem
Tippy Type approached us to assess whether their current website meets user expectations, particularly focusing on lead capture and conversion. They sought deeper insights to refine their understanding of the challenges users face when navigating the site, with the goal of enhancing the overall user experience and uncovering opportunities for improvement.
Solution
To evaluate how well Tippy Type's website aligns with user needs and business goals, we conducted a usability test focused on key user groups: individuals with long nails, influencers, and beauty insiders. We analyzed how effectively these users could complete essential tasks, such as understanding Tippy Type's value, identifying the right product, and signing up for the newsletter. Based on our findings, we delivered a comprehensive report outlining recommendations to optimize the site for smoother navigation, better lead capture, and improved conversions.
The Heuristic Evaluation Work
Heuristic Evaluation
Before conducting usability testing, we performed a heuristic evaluation of the Tippy Type website to identify potential usability issues that might affect user experience. Below are the key findings and recommendations based on Jakob Nielsen’s usability heuristics:
Usability Flexibility Trade-Off
Issue: The website contains an overwhelming amount of text, making it feel more like an informational website than an e-commerce platform.
Recommendation: Prioritize visual content such as product images, clear CTAs (Call-to-Actions), and concise descriptions. Reducing text density and focusing on product presentation will enhance user engagement and ease navigation.
User Control & Freedom
Issue: Users cannot return to the homepage from the affiliate sign-in page when clicking on the Tippy Type logo.
Recommendation: Implement a clear "Home" or "Back" button on every page. This will ensure that users can easily navigate back to the main homepage or product pages without frustration.
Match Between System & Real World
Issue: The website lacks a product gallery, which is commonly expected on e-commerce sites.
Recommendation: Introduce a prominent product gallery on the homepage and product pages to allow users to browse and compare products visually, aligning with real-world user expectations of an e-commerce platform.
Usability Testing
Based on the findings from the heuristic evaluation, we developed a usability testing script to assess how effectively users could perform key tasks on the Tippy Type website. The goal was to determine whether the website meets user expectations and supports their needs throughout the shopping experience.
Usability Testing Script
The script was designed to guide participants through specific tasks, simulating real-life scenarios for Tippy Type’s primary and secondary users. These tasks were chosen to evaluate both the ease of navigation and the overall user experience, particularly lead capture and conversions.
Primary Tasks Tested
Understand the meaning and value of Tippy Type: Can users quickly grasp the concept and benefits of the product?
Identify the appropriate Tippy Type product to purchase: How easily can users find the keyboard cover that suits their needs?
Learn about Tippy Type’s return policy: Are users able to locate clear information regarding returns?
Complete the purchase of a Tippy Type product: Is the checkout process smooth and intuitive?
Request additional information about Tippy Type: Can users easily reach out for more details about the product?
Sign up for the Tippy Type newsletter: Is the newsletter signup process simple and accessible?
These tasks were designed to test the website's ability to help users navigate efficiently, make informed decisions, and complete transactions with minimal friction.
The usability script
Methodology
Each participant was asked to share their experience of using keyboards while having long nails, discussing both challenges and how they adapt. Following this, participants were asked to share their first impressions of the website. After this initial feedback, they were given specific scenarios to further explore their interactions with the site.
Example Scenario Given:
"What company do you think this is?"
Follow-up Questions:"Does anything about the website stand out to you?"
"Are you seeing everything you’d expect to find on a website for this type of company?"
The goal of these scenarios and questions was to gain deeper insights into how users perceived the brand, the design’s effectiveness, and whether it met their expectations based on prior experiences with similar sites.
Method of Testing
We conducted testing with six participants, five of whom were long nail wearers and one who was a beauty insider. All participants regularly shopped online and frequently used their keyboards for work-related tasks.
The testing sessions took place via Zoom and involved a structured team setup, including a moderator, a notetaker, and an observer. Upon joining, the technical person would let the participants into the session. The moderator would guide each participant through the process while the notetaker documented observations. The observer focused on the participants' emotions, all while keeping their camera off to minimize distractions. Only the moderator had their camera on.
Participants were asked about their experiences with long nails and how this impacted their interactions with the keyboard. They provided their first impressions of the website before being presented with specific scenarios. For example, one scenario asked, "What company do you think this is?" followed by prompts such as, "Does anything stand out about it?" and "Are you seeing everything you would expect to find?"
Participants shared their screens to walk through the website, allowing us to observe their navigation and interactions in real-time. With their permission, each session was recorded for later review, enabling us to revisit key moments and analyze details that might have been overlooked during live observations.
Key Findings
Following the usability testing, we synthesized the findings into visual charts and tables for the Tippy Type team. The table below highlights user performance on key tasks, indicating success with a "1" for users who completed the task and an "X" for those who did not.
Summary of Findings:
Success Rate: Only 3 out of 6 tasks were successfully executed by users.
Navigation Challenges: 2 out of 6 users struggled to navigate the homepage effectively.
Finding Information: 1 user was unable to locate the return policy, while another user couldn't find the contact page or the affiliate link.
These findings highlight significant areas for improvement in the website's usability, particularly in enhancing navigation and information accessibility.
Presentation Summary for Tippy Type
I created a comprehensive presentation slide for Tippy Type that encapsulates all key findings from the usability testing. The presentation includes:
Summary of Findings: A detailed overview of user performance across various tasks, highlighting areas of success and challenges encountered.
Visual Data Representation: Charts and tables illustrating task completion rates, making it easier to identify trends and insights.
Recommendations for Improvement: Actionable suggestions aimed at enhancing website navigation, optimizing lead capture, and boosting conversion rates based on user feedback.
This structured approach ensures the client has a clear understanding of the usability testing outcomes and the recommended next steps for refining their website.
Findings & Recommendation Report